Root Cause Analysis Techniques: Fishbone Diagram vs. 5 Whys

7 min read

Root Cause Analysis (RCA) is a fundamental problem-solving methodology used across industries to identify the underlying causes of issues, defects, or failures. Among the various RCA techniques, two of the most commonly used are the Fishbone Diagram and the 5 Whys. Both methods aim to systematically trace the root cause of a problem, but they differ in structure, application, and depth of analysis.

This article provides a comprehensive comparison of these techniques, highlighting their strengths, limitations, and best use cases.

1. Understanding Root Cause Analysis (RCA)

Root Cause Analysis is a systematic process used to identify the fundamental cause(s) of a problem, rather than just addressing its symptoms. RCA helps in:

Preventing the recurrence of issues.
Enhancing product and process quality.
Reducing downtime and costs.
Improving customer satisfaction and organizational efficiency.

Click Here to Join the Over 6500 Students Taking our Highly Rated Courses in Manufacturing, Quality Assurance/Quality Control, Project Management, Engineering, Food Safety, Lean Six Sigma, Industrial Safety (HSE), Lean Manufacturing, Six Sigma, ISO 9001, ISO 14001, ISO 22000, ISO 45001, FSSC 22000, Product Development etc. on UDEMY.

2. Fishbone Diagram (Ishikawa Diagram)

2.1. Overview

The Fishbone Diagram, also known as the Ishikawa Diagram or Cause-and-Effect Diagram, is a visual tool used to systematically identify and analyze the potential causes of a problem. The diagram resembles a fish skeleton, with the problem as the "head" and the causes branching out as "bones."

2.2. Structure

The Fishbone Diagram typically categorizes causes into major groups, such as:

People: Human-related factors, such as skills, training, or motivation.
Methods: Processes, procedures, or workflows.
Machines: Equipment, tools, or technology.
Materials: Raw materials, components, or consumables.
Environment: Physical conditions, such as temperature, humidity, or noise.
Measurements: Data collection, monitoring, or metrics.

2.3. Steps to Create a Fishbone Diagram

Define the Problem: Clearly state the problem and place it at the "head" of the fish.
Identify Major Categories: Select the categories relevant to the problem.
Brainstorm Possible Causes: For each category, brainstorm potential causes and add them as branches.
Analyze the Diagram: Evaluate the potential causes and identify the root cause(s).

2.4. Advantages

Provides a comprehensive, visual representation of possible causes.
Encourages team collaboration and brainstorming.
Categorizes causes for easier analysis.

2.5. Limitations

Can become complex for large problems with many causes.
Requires a facilitator with experience to guide the process effectively.

Click Here to Join the Over 6500 Students Taking our Highly Rated Courses in Manufacturing, Quality Assurance/Quality Control, Project Management, Engineering, Food Safety, Lean Six Sigma, Industrial Safety (HSE), Lean Manufacturing, Six Sigma, ISO 9001, ISO 14001, ISO 22000, ISO 45001, FSSC 22000, Product Development etc. on UDEMY.

3. 5 Whys Technique

3.1. Overview

The 5 Whys is a simple, iterative technique used to drill down into the root cause of a problem by repeatedly asking "Why?" until the fundamental cause is identified. It is often used in lean manufacturing, Six Sigma, and quality management systems.

3.2. Structure

The 5 Whys technique is linear, focusing on one causal chain at a time.

3.3. Steps to Perform the 5 Whys

Define the Problem: Clearly articulate the problem.
Ask the First Why: Identify the immediate cause of the problem.
Ask Subsequent Whys: For each answer, ask "Why?" again, typically five times, until the root cause is reached.
Identify Corrective Actions: Once the root cause is identified, determine appropriate corrective actions.

3.4. Example

Problem: A machine stopped working.

Why did the machine stop?
→ The motor stopped running.
Why did the motor stop running?
→ The fuse blew.
Why did the fuse blow?
→ The motor was overloaded.
Why was the motor overloaded?
→ The lubrication system failed.
Why did the lubrication system fail?
→ It was not maintained as per schedule.
Root Cause: Lack of maintenance.

3.5. Advantages

Simple and easy to implement.
Does not require specialized tools or training.
Quickly identifies a single root cause.

3.6. Limitations

Focuses on a single causal chain, which may overlook other contributing factors.
Effectiveness depends on the accuracy of answers and the facilitator's experience.

Click Here to Join the Over 6500 Students Taking our Highly Rated Courses in Manufacturing, Quality Assurance/Quality Control, Project Management, Engineering, Food Safety, Lean Six Sigma, Industrial Safety (HSE), Lean Manufacturing, Six Sigma, ISO 9001, ISO 14001, ISO 22000, ISO 45001, FSSC 22000, Product Development etc. on UDEMY.

4. Comparison: Fishbone Diagram vs. 5 Whys

Criteria	Fishbone Diagram	5 Whys
Approach	Visual, categorizes multiple potential causes.	Linear, focuses on a single causal chain.
Complexity	Can handle complex problems with multiple causes.	Best suited for simpler problems with one primary cause.
Collaboration	Encourages group brainstorming and input.	Can be performed individually or with a small group.
Depth of Analysis	Broad analysis covering various categories.	Deep, focused analysis on a single causal path.
Ease of Use	Requires some facilitation and structure.	Simple and intuitive, requires minimal training.
Best Use Case	Complex problems with multiple potential causes.	Simple problems or when a quick solution is needed.

5. Choosing the Right Technique

When to Use the Fishbone Diagram

The problem has multiple potential causes.
A team-based approach is desired.
The problem is complex and requires categorization.

When to Use the 5 Whys

The problem is relatively simple.
A quick and straightforward solution is required.
Resources and time are limited.

Click Here to Join the Over 6500 Students Taking our Highly Rated Courses in Manufacturing, Quality Assurance/Quality Control, Project Management, Engineering, Food Safety, Lean Six Sigma, Industrial Safety (HSE), Lean Manufacturing, Six Sigma, ISO 9001, ISO 14001, ISO 22000, ISO 45001, FSSC 22000, Product Development etc. on UDEMY.

6. Integrating Both Techniques

In many cases, it is beneficial to use both techniques together. For example:

Start with a Fishbone Diagram to identify all potential causes.
Use the 5 Whys to drill down into each potential cause to find the root cause.

This integrated approach combines the breadth of the Fishbone Diagram with the depth of the 5 Whys, providing a more comprehensive RCA process.

7. Conclusion

Both the Fishbone Diagram and the 5 Whys are powerful tools for root cause analysis, each with its unique strengths and limitations. By understanding when and how to use these techniques, organizations can effectively identify and address the root causes of problems, leading to improved processes, products, and overall performance. Whether used independently or together, these techniques can be invaluable assets in any continuous improvement or quality management initiative.

Collection of In-Demand Industry Courses:

1. MANUFACTURING, QUALITY, PRODUCT DEVELOPMENT, OPERATIONS & SUPPLY CHAIN MANAGEMENT

2. ISO MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS IMPLEMENTATION & INTERNAL AUDITOR COURSES

3. ISO LEAD AUDITOR COURSES

Root Cause Analysis Techniques: Fishbone Diagram vs. 5 Whys

Comments